Look, the pizza is good however I can't say I'm not a little disappointed based on the expectations I had from the 4.5 star rating!
Pluses:
- Crust is nice and chewy
- Pizza overall tastes good, though the sauce is a little bland
- Decent amount of toppings (we got the House Special), not overloaded by any means
- Price - medium house special was 16.50 tax in, which was a reasonable amount of food for 2 guys and one girl, not tons though
Minuses
- the wait at 7:45pm on a Thursday was 50 minutes (luckily Yelp prepared us for that)
- the pizza did not look like the one used for the profile pic (eg. that one appears to be just overloaded with cheese and toppings... was there double cheese on that?)
Overall
I would go there again if its convenient. Also, I'd give it another try to see whether I just got a mediocre pizza (for them) on the day we ordered.