Went in for the first time today because I was in the area buying a concert ticket at Rotate This. I had had a previous stab at going to Poutini when I was going to a concert some time ago at the Drake but I found it closed (I went to Pho Tien Thanh instead).
The first thing I immediately notice when I walk in is the lack of seats to this place when there is clearly enough room for more. I ordered the layered poutine. Although I knew of this beforehand, I was still struck by the chutzpah they had in charging extra for layering even if the cost is really based on "extra cheese" (even though the amount of cheese they put in the layered should be the norm rather than the exception). Paid the exact 9.99 (thought it was kind of cute but annoying at the same time how they probably purposely chose a price that would give 9.99 with tax) for it and walked out.
Fries were crispy and rather tasty just by themselves. Gravy isn't too shabby but not great either. Some of the cheese still felt kind of cold or room temp although I had been outside for all of a minute and a half before I started eating it. It was above average for a poutine in Toronto (which isn't saying much) but for 10 bucks, the value is just not there at all.