I had a great experience working with Craig's Cakes without ever having visited Wisconsin! At first, I was a bit apprehensive because I needed a cake delivered by the next day for a friend's birthday and the website indicated at least a week's notice. However, the person I spoke to on the phone was extremely accommodating and was able to help me get one ready by tomorrow! Apparently, carrot cake takes the longest for them to prepare and bake, so they were unable to fulfill that particular request (my fault for not calling a week ahead). I ordered a 6 inch red velvet cake with cheesecake filling instead. Delivery fee (at least within Verona) was $10. I can't speak for taste, but I am very satisfied with their service and would recommend them to anyone needing a cake delivered in Wisconsin!