Paper Skyscraper is the quirkiest! I usually don't go overboard about stationary, but this place is the real deal when it comes to small gifts and knick knacks. I'm always surprised to find trinkets like piggy banks for plastic surgery and divorces, not mention greeting cards that celebrate the most awkward events in life and nostalgic fridge magnets that are less-than-wholesome.
I'm not good at buying gifts, but Paper Skyscraper makes it alot easier. I always find some item in this store that complements the idiosyncrasies of the person for whom I'm buying a gift. If you only have a few $$$ to spend on a gift and want something more personable and memorable than a gift card, P.S is the place. There's something crude, off-kilter, and unique in everyone and this store is the place to indulge those things.