I came here just once over the summer and probably will not return. I walk by the red bench all the time and always see people eating these delicious looking cookie ice cream sandwiches and one day I finally decided to go in and try it. The person behind the counter was not very friendly. There were no other customers there and we took some time deciding what to try since we had never been there before. I asked for recommendations and she didn't really give me any and didn't offer any information. She looked really impatient while waiting for us.
The sandwiches look really good, but the cookies were very stale and dry. They have just rows and rows of cookies sitting out and I don't think that many are sold, so it seems like the cookies just sit there for a long time. The ice cream was passable. Overall the sandwich wasn't expensive, but I wouldn't come back for this. You'd be better off buying cookies at tim hortons or subway and scooping some random ice cream into it.