Luckily living close to this location, it's one of our favorite stops! I've never had a bad thing here as far as food is concerned. The colossal fish, cheese-steak, corned beef and egg, smallman street fries and fried pickles are some favorites! Sandwiches here are great every time with one exception of a colossal fish that was more deep fried breading than fish and had been clearly sitting under a heat lamp too long; but normally this is not the case.
The only reason I have to give this particular location of Primanti brother's 4 out of 5 stars is the service. It is often hit or miss with this place. The reason we like Primanti's is that it can be a quick place to grab a bite to eat and not somewhere where you wait endlessly for your meal. We almost always sit at the "seat yourself" bar area and are usually greeted by a waitress right away. However, sometimes once seated it can take us 30-45 minutes to eat or up to 2 hours for a party of TWO to eat and get out of there. It really just depends on the day for whatever reason. The waitresses are never rude, however everything just can be VERY slow and sometimes I have been there for dinner, had to wait and never had my drink re-filled unless I asked several times. This is a pet peeve for me.
If you are in Pittsburgh, it's definitely worth a trip, but just be sure you're not in a hurry...