This is actually a 3-4 star restaurant... depending on what time you go. If you go unprepared (sans-coupons) at dinnertime, you WILL get screwed over by the outrageous prices that the regular menu features. I would go for the pasta, since the servings are more generous than pretty much anything else. Second choice would be the sandwiches.
With that said, I went at lunchtime and got a delicious filet mignon steak sandwich, which only costs about 9 or 10 bucks and came with delicious fries, sauteed mushrooms & onions, and melted provolone cheese that soaked up the rich steak reduction beautifully.
Well worth my money for lunch, especially since I had coupon that allowed for the second entree - for my best female friend Natasha - to be free so long as you order two drinks. Sweetwater IPA For. The. Win.