First of all this review is focused on the cheesecakes only - I haven't tried any of the savoury items and so far I've only ordered cheesecakes to go.
Carole's Cheesecake is one of my favourite places to go if I'm craving a good slice of cake. I've been meaning to try the New York Cheesecake because it's the classic option and it looks delicious, but then I end up having a look at the variety of flavours they have and I always end up ordering something with berries, or Oreos, or cookies, or caramel... their caramel brownie cheesecake is out of this world.
Service is always quick and a-OK, but again it is a quick interaction because I use to order cake to go. Anyway, I highly recommend this place if you find yourself near Bloor/Bay and are craving good cheesecake.