How did I find New Amsterdam? I was walking along Butler one Saturday evening and we heard a bunch of people sounding like they were having a good time. It was New Amsterdam. They have 2 stories... 2 bars and a really nice vibe. Their beer selection was pretty good.
Upon entry we had to show out ID, which I was totally fine with. The bar downstairs was packed full of people who were all engaged in various conversations. We headed upstairs since we were a part of a larger group (10 people). The weather held up so it was a lovely day.
The bathroom is basically in the basement so be prepared to walk a lot of stairs if you're all the way upstairs.
Side Note: I don't remember it being a dance club??? I think when we left the DJ was getting ready to play. I'll have to come back for some dancing fun!