We have been here several times and haven't been disappointed in the food once. The meatballs are always fresh, tender, and juicy. Their pork bolognese has a hint of sweet spice to it, so heads up of you prefer a more acidic red sauce. Their mushroom gravy has a hint of nostalgia for grandma's beef stroganoff and the buffalo balls are can't miss.
It does not get more stars due to the shoddy service by their serving staff. The best service we have gotten was seated at the bar. Each time we have table service, orders are wrong, drinks are never refilled or are forgotten about. During one trip, the server took my boyfriend's food and drink order first (big no-no, ladies first!) and then walked away from the table! She never even got mine. She returned later with my boyfriend's beer, and we had to informer that she never took my order. Needless to say, my boyfriend's food showed up 15 minutes before mine. If they fix their serving staff, it could easily be one of the best casual dining experiences in Pittsburgh.