I had really high hopes coming here for the first time but unfortunately it did not meet my expectations.
Came here on a Friday afternoon with 2 of my cousins and my brother. We all got a full ice cream sandwich ($6) but you can also get a half cookie ($4). We got to choose 2 different cookies or 2 of the same ones, 1 flavour of ice cream and 1 topping. I got a brookie (brownie + cookie) and s'mores cookie for my sandwich, white chocolate raspberry ice cream and roasted almonds for my topping. First warning sign, our server who was also the cashier did not change his plastic gloves when making our sandwiches. I was the only one to pay cash but I ordered second and he gave me my change back with his gloves still on.. greasy and gross! He then proceeded to make my cousin's sandwich. The tables were not wiped down and had coffee or tea stains on them but I guess with the amount of people in the shop they just never got around to it? I'm very particular about my ice cream sandwiches meaning I like the ice cream to be really cold and solid while the cookie slightly soft and chewy. Total opposite. The ice cream melted very quickly and was a very thin layer - probably because their cookies are so wide. The whole thing combined was just sickeningly sweet and I may be to blame because I chose the flavours. My cousin ended up throwing out the rest of her sandwich out because the ice cream and cookie combination was just too overwhelming.
Overall, neither of my cousins nor my brother thought this place was spectacular. I really want to love this place but after my first experience here, I don't think I'll be back anytime soon.
If you do happen to stop by, I'd recommend ordering a half sandwich instead.