We were overwhelmed by the lack of space in here and almost turned around. Some friendly customers who were waiting for their food advised us we should definitely stay. They promised it was worth it.
The super nice guys behind the counter were very helpful in explaining the menu. Specifically: the OPTION. Portabello + Cheese + Deepfried = SOLD. The Priest is a juicy burger plus the option. Whoa. I couldn't possibly handle that.
I was not impressed with the drink options. Very boooooooooorrrrring.
There were zero seats available when we arrived. I should mention they only have a total of 3 and a half seats (or something like that). We were told seats would free up by the time our food was ready, and sure enough they did! Tip: I gave up my seat super early (probably still chewing the last bits of my burger) and got a big compliment for it! Diners seem to be very appreciative of seating, especially in the middle of winter.
I have had cravings for the Option ever since and have only been back once. It's a little out of the way, but well worth the trip.
My most recent visit was on a hot day and it was twenty times hotter in the Priest. Ugh. We didn't even consider sitting inside and instead wandered across the street to a cute little park. There's a picnic table there!