I have really fond memories of this place when it was Todd English P.U.B., and this was my first visit back since the change. The beer selection was fine, the bartender was friendly, and the food was... uninspiring. I get that it's not fine dining, but this was on the low end of what I'd consider pub fare.
However, I'm giving it an extra star because it provided me with some of the best entertainment of my trip. A guy a few seats down from me at the bar ordered a pastrami sandwich. He was really unhappy with the quality of the pastrami, and proceeded to have the absolute weirdest reaction I've ever seen. He proclaimed LOUDLY that he didn't want a discount and didn't want to make a big deal of it but that it was the WORST quality pastrami he ever experienced. He really didn't want a discount, a refund, or a replacement - apparently he just wanted to lecture every single staff member about the evils of low-quality pastrami and the perils of buying your meat from the lowest-cost bidder. For a good 45 minutes. Maybe he was a meat salesman? The extra star is for the staff, who were unfailingly polite to this weirdo.
Edit to add that the lady who sat down after meat critic left also ordered the pastrami and seemed to enjoy it.