First visit on a Friday with spouse and couple-guests.
As other reviewers have mentioned... old-school, classic, stuffy, etc... yep.
The food was solid (I had the potato-crusted Grouper) and most others had steak of some sort. No surprises on the salads or sides... (potato and asparagus? Why yes, we do have those and would be delighted to include them on just about everything.)
I was a bit (pleasantly) surprised to see the inside so empty on a Friday early-evening, as it meant our table could enjoy conversation without being rushed toward the door. That alone is worth the extra dollar or two per dish.
Johnny's is a good spot, just don't go into this looking for something innovative or trendy. Sometimes, that's just perfect.