Carly's is a solid 3 start joint.
Most of the food here I can easily make at home. The feta rosa is really really delicious though.
The live music here can be a little much sometimes. Especially when it's 5 pm on a Monday and a trumpet is blaring in your ear when you're trying to enjoy your Carly-Q. It makes having a conversation literally impossible, unless you want to get laryngitis.
I like that they have their $2 (or maybe its $3 now?) rotating draft. But it's almost always either Session or Kronenbourg. If you live downtown it's totes worth checking out.