Legit NYC style pizza right down to the white tiled hole in the wall setting, complete with pinball machines and signed dollar bills taped up next to the register.
The crust is just the right thickness and almost has a bit of a sourdough flavor. The sauce is mild and subtle, and the cheese is perfectly proportioned. The pepperoni and meatball toppings are both winners.
The staff has that New York sass to them, but always provide solid service.
I don't care if it's a ridiculous $4.50 per slice, Secret Pizza is the best slice in town, is worth a special trip, and is my go-to when I get that craving for a good slice or four.