The name describes in perfect order what I liked best. Frozen custard over the steakburger. My girlfriend and I rolled in at about 10:30 after a 2-mile run determined to completely throw away the exercise we had just done. We landed on the Turtle concrete mixer based on the giant sign hanging above the register, which called to me like a sirens song in the night. It's aura of deliciousness was too enticing to pass up. Next I decided to add a steakburger to the order because I felt it was essential to complete the full, first-time experience.
When our order arrived at our table just a couple of minutes later I noticed the burger looked a little greasy, but what the hell, I dove right in. I found the burger to be overly salty and left something to be desired flavor wise. As for the concrete mixer, due to the temperature of the hot fudge they threw in it turned out to be more like a glass of chocolate soup. I would have expected this if I ordered a fudge sundae, but it's not really what a concrete mixer should be. Overall, the flavor was very good.
The staff was super friendly and helpful and I enjoyed the decor, but honestly I was hoping for a little more from this place.