Mitchell's has some really good ice cream. I mean, it's no East Coast Custard, but the variety almost makes up for it. There are tons of unique choices each time, and plenty of old standbys.
The Ohio City location is cool. Nice and roomy and bright, and the train that goes around the restaurant is soothing. It is best to go to the second floor, where you can watch them making ice cream. And a perk is that it stays open til midnight on weekends. Score after a few beers at Nano Brew!