I definitely would have to give Matts a 4 stars max, could not give it a 5 stars because I do believe they are of a five star quality but lack any originality as say a Liberty Market.
Have heard a ton about Matts and I do have to say that they have quality food, Went there and had waffles with bacon and a side order of potatoes. They do make basic food very well and that is a good but it is basic food. Nothing imaginative or out of the ordinary, so nothing to really to say WOW that is something new. Again though they do basic food very well which is harder said then done, and that is why I would recommend it, I would not go out of my way though just because of the location and the size of the place, but I only judge by food. If you can get in the food is very good even great.