This place opened a few years back while I was making my exodus from the Madison area and then from the country. While making the occasional visit to family over the past couple years, I'd heard good things. And being back in WI for a few months, I thought it was time to check it out.
The other reviews are spot-on: this place is great. Although a bit fancy-looking to really live up to its supper club heritage, the food is absolutely great. Even my Scottish fiance was enamoured.
Great food (try the beer cheese soup!), an amazing beverage selection, and very attentive & friendly service.
We're recommending this place to friends coming to town for our wedding. Especially the foreigners - it'll give them an amazing taste of the best state. :)