Every time I've been to the tipsy cow I've enjoyed it, and I've been there... roughly 8-10 times. Why I keep going back: The food!!!!!
I initially went for it's decently priced fish fry which I think is the best in town, perhaps some of the best I've EVER had, and I've had many a fish fry over the years.
Also... their curds are... oh.my. GOD. soooo good.
The truffle fries are unique and also good but I do somewhat feel like I gain a food baby after eating them - definitely a great thing to share!
The service is somewhat hit-or-miss, but it's never been terrible. It's always a place I suggest, oh and if you do go to the fish fry, prepare to wait awhile. but its worth it.