Its cool that they use a historical building that looks like it hasn't much in the last 100 years. Its too bad there food probably hasn't improved with the times though.
The bread is good, the steaks are mediocre. The place is super dimly lit inside. I do recommend that you at least go and try it once since it is a piece of Tempe history.
*insider tip: have drinks on the outside patio when there is a good concert going on at Tempe beach park.