I came here due to my bae living right around the corner. They are in the plaza with Food Lion.
We came seeking single slices to try the most toppings we could. Service was okay, the cashier seemed like she didn't want to be there but I won't take it personal. The owner or possibly the manager, was hospitable though. We chose to take it to go and it didn't take long... no more than 10 minutes.
I got the white pizza and the pepperoni. The bae got supreme and pepperoni/sausage. We tore the pizza up! It was pretty good. I don't know what NY pizza tastes like so I can't confirm the authenticity but I liked it. It was definitely filling. The cheese wasn't the freshest but it was better than store bought.
Also, I didn't see any roaches inside the store. After looking at some other reviews I definitely looked.