I usually come to Sheriff's for their wings, but I wanted to wait until I tried a few other menu items before I wrote my review.
This is how it breaks down...
The wings are exactly what you might expect from a good to average broaster place. The outside is crisp with a little extra kick (if you opt for mild). The best deal is 24 whole wings for $25. Apart from the standard sauces (bbq, honey garlic, etc), Sheriff's also has a homemade white garlic sauce. The flavour is robust and pairs well with a bit of siracha (one of my dad's favourite mixes). I will definitely return for more wings.
If you just came for wings you can stop reading here because this is where I start to rant... While Sheriff's has gotten their wings down to a science, the rest of their food is pretty bad. The shwarmas taste burnt, that is whatever you can taste through their overpowering spicy sauce. Also don't look into your wrap since all else you will find are some wrinkly potato wedges and wilted lettuce. Truly, the taste of sadness....
As for the fries ...they are mushy. The poutine is nothing like a Canadian poutine and to even call this concoction "poutine" with it's thin gravy and scant smattering of cheese would be an insult.
My conclusion...good broasted wings, but not much else.