The Mayfield Smoke shop is a cute little Cigar store. They had a wonderful selection of sticks. Everything from $5 CAO's to high end Cigars like Ashton's and Cohiba's. My visit was typical of many Cigar shops I've experienced. You get the evil eye from the regulars as soon as you open the door. Once they realize you know your Cigars, they go about their business and move onto to other things.
I found a hidden Gem at Mayfield. They carry the Miami made, El Titan de Bronze. For those of you who haven't tried this wonderful, Miami-made Cigar, I highly recommend it. Its a tasty stick that's reasonably priced. You won't find a better Cigar in the $7 range. This store was stocked to the nines and had something for everyone.
Here's the smoky bottom line: The Mayfield Smoke shop is officially my go to Cigar store in Cleveland. They have everything a Cigar junkie like me could ask for and its all reasonably priced. I can't wait for my return visit.