Pistachio & Strawberry Cheesecake Gelato ($2.75 for small, $3.25 for medium)
All the gelato at this cafe are handmade, ingredients straight from Italy. They don't have a lot of flavors in house, but still a good variety. The owner is really friendly and encourages you to sample different flavors before choosing one. You also have the option to mix 2 flavors as well. The strawberry cheesecake gelato flavor was good but after eating it half way through it felt slightly on the sour end and tasted less cheesecakey. However, the pistachio flavor was BOMB! It's one of the best pistachio gelato I've had. The flavor was really rich.
I personally think the small and medium sizes of the gelato are really similar - slightly expensive for its portion.