Popped in here to try and energize myself for an hour-long TTC ride home and my non-expectations were blown away. I really just picked this place at random for a quick bite and drink and ended up getting a meat sandwich (smoked meat with tomatoes), a walnut butter square, and an iced tea (some kind of Earl Grey with apricot preserves).
About the venue: I was a little confused by the space, especially the bar of sandwiches in front. They're not self-serve although they look like they might be. The seating looked to be mostly stools but they have a patio in the back with 2-3 picnic tables and a fire pit.
About the comestibles: They were amazing. The butter square was nicely chewy and sweet and the walnuts were well-integrated. The smoked meat was very simple - literally bread, meat, and tomato - but so well composed and almost elegantly done. The tea, recommended to me by a friendly staff member, was the star - a little sweetened, very fresh, very flavorful. Not weak in flavor but mellow.
I would definitely come back if I was in the area. As everyone mentioned, they have punch cards.