This place is under new management. The owners moved out of state and have turned it over to a friend who plans to continue in the tradition of it's previous owners per an article in The Onion.
The store is neat and clean and the staff is very pleasant and friendly.
They apparently have live music come in during the month and also have artwork from local artists which is great!
You should check it out.
Update: They have moved to 817 E Johnson St. It's a nice location with on street parking. This is only 8 blocks from the previous location. Instead of going up to near the square, turn on Livingston and go 3 blocks to E Johnson. Take a right and it is on your right. This place gets better year by year.