So I wish I could give 3.5 stars but I'm rounding down since that's not possible.
I've eaten here 4 times. 2 were great! The first time I had the Cajun chicken alfredo it was amazing!!! The service here has always been good and I love the beer flights in the clover shaped serving blocks. The other time I had the burger then comes in between a grilled cheese....I'm not sure what it's called but it's wonderful! My boyfriend got this once and then later on we both got it and all 3 burgers from there were excellent. I've also had a few good bloody Mary's here as well and the bartenders are friendly and competent. I'd give the atmosphere in the bar area 4/5 stars as well.
The other 2 times....well, I'm not sure if they have changed kitchen staff but the 2nd time I got the very same Cajun Alfredo (about 3 months after the first time) it was cold, tasted terrible, and had no kick to it. There's no way it was the same recipe that I had the first time, and I was so disappointed in the result that I'm afraid to try it again. I also came during breakfast hours once and ordered a quesadilla. When this arrived the bottom of the plate was covered in water like someone had knocked a glass over on it but decided to serve it anyway, and I ended up with a soggy mess that was not edible.
Bottom line I guess is that when it's good, it's really good! When it's bad, it's very bad. :( that makes it hard to write a solid review. They do have a good beer selection here and I will be back. Hopefully next time will be one of the better times! The