I LOVE Mitchell's! I have dreams about their ice cream!
I've been here twice and have been pleased with their ice cream and service both times. My husband always gets a chocolate shake, which is amazing, especially topped with their homemade whipped cream and chocolate shavings. I've had the Salted Caramel and the Chocolate Chunk Coffee ice creams and both are really delicious: great consistency with a lot of flavor. I can't decide which is my favorite! Their ice cream cones are fresh and never stale. They also sell their flavors in take home tubs, which is handy if you want to stock your freezer.
They have a lot of tables and it's always been pretty busy when I've gone. Can't wait to head back here for more ice cream!