Great Scott's is the best option for pizza in town. We've always had great service and only once have we had a pizza that wasn't the greatest quality. When we called to comment about it, the owner remade our pizza and delivered it to us himself!
They have a variety of specialty pizzas, or you can make your own. The pizza is always hot and fresh with the right combination of ingredients. We prefer the hand tossed crust, which isn't too thick, but still has good substance.
Delivery service is fantastic! The delivery drivers are very nice and polite. They are always prepared with a pen (if needed to sign a CC slip) or readily available change for cash. They have always been very genial with us.
Great Scott's is my family's go-to place when we've had a long day and don't feel like cooking, or we are having company over and want an easy dinner. The food is fresh and hot, well prepared, reasonable in cost, and delivered pretty quickly. Having tried the other places for pizza in Mount Horeb (pizza hut and Grumpy Troll) I definitely recommend Great Scott's over the competition.