My favorite pizza in the Lyndhurst/Mayfield/South Euclid. Crust is good, sauce is great, toppings used are top notch. They're not blazing trails in terms of inventing new types of pizza. But if you want a traditional pepperoni and sausage pizza you can't beat it. When I was in Vegas, I went to Grimaldi's at the Palazzo which supposedly is one of the Top 10 pizza places in the country. They have nothing on Vicinato's.
The one knock on them is they don't deliver so plan on picking up or sitting down and ordering like a traditional restaurant. It is definitely more of a sit down restaurant with carryout rather than the type of place centered around carryout and delivery.