Made a special trip since I've heard such good things and I was really disappointed. Tried the mad cow (I think it was called), the one with the cheeseburger and their "veggie burger" (aka portobello mushrooms stuffed with cheese and deep fried) and my husband had the holy chuck burger. We also shared a poutine.
The burger itself is under seasoned and not super flavourful (needs more salt and pepper). Their veggie "burger" (the mushrooms) was really disappointing (the burgers priest one is much better). You can barely taste the mushrooms and the cheese they use (feta and cream cheese), has no real taste or cheesiness. Honestly, I could taste the breading more than anything.
The buns didn't seem fresh and honestly tasted and looked like week old wonder bread buns you may get at the grocery store.
The holy chuck burger - same under seasoned party and bun. The best part was the carmelized onions... which isn't saying much.
The poutine was alright. I found the gravy a little too salty.
Tried the Reece's and banana shake, which was tasty and the highlight of the meal.
The burgers were really disappointing - def prefer burgers priest or even south st to be honest
Their fries are better than burgers priest though but that's not a good enough reason to come back.
Id like to tell myself it was awesome before and has just gone down in quality... I doubt I'll come back.