I will start off by saying that ordering a whole pizza is expensive, but in this situation the price and product match up completely. I've not only never had a problem with their food or service, but I would say that their pizza is definitely worth it. Best in Madison? No I wouldn't go that far but it's definitely good. I gave this pizza place three stars because in my personal opinion it's pricey. At least mine was. One pizza could be anywhere from $20 - $25 so that's definitely a lot for one pizza, but the pizza is definitely good. The order times can be spotty at times and the My order has been wrong once, but this doesn't warrant a non recommendation from me. It's just something to keep in mind when you order. I haven't been to the other locations but as far as the Monona location goes, this is probably the strongest out of all of them from what other reviews have indicated.