Undercooked Shrimp.
Let me start by saying that the majority of my food was delicious, I ordered the shrimp and grits. MY wife ordered the chicken and mac & cheese, which was satisfactory. I would have given this a four-star review.
HOWEVER, I had one grey, veiny shrimp in my dish, which was obviously undercooked compared to the rest on the plate. When I informed my waiter, he brought it back to the chef, who stated that shrimp from Florida do not change color like normal shrimp (even though the other five shrimp on my plate were more than deliciously colored), and assured me that it was indeed cooked through. Not being one to think I am above making mistakes, I tried it- still obviously grey and undercooked.
I know that the customer is not always right, but chef... neither are you. We will not be returning.