Perhaps my expectations were too high.
I have a tendency to compare this type of restaurant to middle eastern / Mediterranean restaurants in Illinois.
Even by wisconsin standards both of the entrees I sampled fell flat. It seemed like everything was under salted and under seasoned. Chicken Schwarma sandwich seemed to be plain chicken breast strips on a pita. The beef kebab was equally unimpressive. Even the tzatziki for the sandwich fell flat.
Madison does not have many options when I get the Mediterranean itch, but I doubt I'll be back to Freska.