So I never even got to try anything from here because they have appalling customer service.
I tried to order a pumpkin pie in store and was told to call the retail number, that the order couldn't be taken in store at that time. So I called that number and was told (after the phone rang and rang and rang) to leave an order message on the wholesale line instead. I did just that, and the next day when I called to ask if the pie was put aside, I was simply told that they had "lots". I was coming from north of the city and preferred confirmation that one was being held for me, not to be met with disappointment as I was the day before by going there and being told they sold out.
Needless to say, I did not bother making the trip and ended up picking up a pie from somewhere much closer and with superior service - and that actually smelled and looked like a bakery.