UPDATE: June 18, 2018
This experience really renders 2.5 stars. I went with the Super Mario on pesto bread. My fiancé decided to get the Stallion on garlic cheese bread. We also got an order of 6 mini cookies and the bacon potato salad.
I was so excited to see 2 cookies pop out of my sandwich wrapping. Unfortunately, those cookies were really dry... dare I say pretty stale too?
My sandwich - oh boy. There was so much balsamic vinegar! It wasn't very appealing and the bottom layer of bread holding my sandwich couldn't do its job. It was just a wet mess so that made it a pretty disappointing sandwich. The balsamic was just dripping everywhere.
My fiancé's sandwich - Like I said earlier, he had the Stallion on garlic cheese bread. He said it was the bleu cheese bread even though we ordered the garlic cheese. Bummer... I'm definitely not a fan of bleu cheese so I did not want to verify it.
If I knew the cookies were going to be this dry/stale, I wouldn't have wasted my money on them. The last time we got them, they were soft and chewy! Ugh.
The bacon potato salad. Another let down. We both tossed it because it was so bland and not worth the calories.
I REALLY want to like this place. Maybe third times the charm? I'll just have to convince my fiancé.