So I gave AJ's another chance and stopped by tonight. My wife and daughter had the chicken sandwich and thought it was one of the best they have ever had. Very juicy and flavorful. I had the "sconnie" and it was quite flavorful but almost a bit too much bacon for me.
The fry's were hot and plentiful as were the onion strings. But the best part of the whole meal was the cheese curds!!! Perfectly done, lightly breaded with the best dipping sauce I've ever had. It's a chipotle dip and has a nice bite to it, and just went great with the curds.
A fun place to go with very good sandwiches and appetizers.