The menu is always on point. we usually start with an appetizer, usually the Spanakopita or my personal favorite, Saganaki. When I come, I mostly order the chicken or pork souvlaki. I find the flavor and moisture of everything to be quite decent, not too salty, delicious greek salad - I have never had any reason to complain about anything - been about 5 times in total.
The atmosphere is low key and the service staff are polite, on their game, and consistent. The waitresses are also pretty cute.
I will most definitely be returning - in Danforth Greek town, an area being steam rolled over by new corporate owned restaurants - it's refreshing to have Pappa's Grill keep it on a personal level. My genuine feelings are that food is only as good as the people who cook it - I usually have better experiences with restaurants where the business owner has an active role in the restaurant service chain rather than playing no participating role at all.