I got hooked on the Animal Lover's pizza when I worked at the Madison Children's Museum, and it's by far my favorite veggie pizza in town. Roasted red peppers and the perfect amount of cheese just hit the spot for me. I've also fallen into a dangerous love affair with their herbed breadsticks - if there was no minimum delivery I'd probably just order them alone and shame-eat the whole box.
For a stretch of time I had a really, really hard time getting delivery from this location via their online system - even at 6 o'clock on a weeknight it would tell me that there were no more available delivery times that night despite being open until 10. After a year or so of not ordering from them I tried again and the last few times I've had no issues.
Keep an eye out for coupons - Roman Candle isn't cheap, but the upside is that you get what you pay for and the ingredients have always been fresh and flavorful.