4/5 stars because we found 90% of what was on our Menard's shopping list. Yay!
We visited on a Saturday afternoon and the store was moderately busy. A couple of employees offered us assistance, which was much appreciated.
I think the prices at Menard's are on point; especially for obscure food items and things you aren't necessarily going to Menard's to pick-up in the first place. We scored a great deal on LaCroix sparking water---less than $3.50 for a 12-pack. Menard's price for Charmin toilet paper wasn't bad, either.
Would definitely return again, even though it's across town for us. Some of the deals are too good to pass up. Watch the weekly circulars.