Long story short: Great beer and food not too bad. Not great but something you taste and be like, oh this isn't half bad but probably will not order again.
Beer: 5 stars. My friend and I got their beer sampler - $12.95 as of 2017! Came in 8 different kinds. My friend loved the IPAs and I loved a pale ale and lager. I wish I wrote the name of the lager because it was something I would drink everyday!
Food: 3 stars. Or maybe 3.5 since 3 sounds too harsh. We got bar foods to go along with the beer: fries, nachos, and pierogis. Foolproof bets for food. But fries were little stale, nachos had a ton of chips and not too much toppings, pierogis were decent but nothing to write home about (I mean pierogis never can be bad. Lk that's their definition almost).
Decor/ambience/etc: THE REASON YOU GO HERE. It's a church. With beer. I think that's the selling point. It's really pretty inside. Worth going when you're in Pittsburgh on a visit.