I've been wanting to try this spot for awhile as their photos were coming up on my Yelp feed and it looked very good. We finally made it last night. Our very first initial thought was a little skeptical because the 2 of us tried to sit at a table for 4 (we got there 30 minutes before it closed on a Wednesday night), and we spotted the sign that said "If you're a party of 2, sit at a table for 2!" The guy quickly asked us to change tables (even though there were a lot of empty tables). He seemed a little irritated we were going to sit there. Our actual waiter (Anthony), however, was very nice and laid back.
We ordered a shrimp po boy with cilantro slaw and an oyster po boy with slaw. I would've liked to have tried one of their entrees, but it was higher than my budget allowed (to clarify, I do not think it was overpriced at all... just didn't have a lot of money to spend on dinner last night). The sandwiches were very nice and flavorful. The bread was soft and a great compliment to the seafood. The jury is still out for me with the cilantro slaw. I usually like cilantro, but I just couldn't eat a lot of the slaw.
I would like to go back again when I've got more money to taste some of their entrees. They close a little early as well (again, not a bad thing... you just have to be organized).