Well, I tried again and still not too impressed. This time I ordered early and to-go. A simple cheese calzone. And it was good! But not the best I have ever had and very very heavy. Lots of oil/greese and the cheese wasn't really part of the calzone since as soon as you took one bite it fell out. The crust was just really really hard and overall the cheese mixture was kind of strange in texture and followed through with the taste.
But it's Little Italy, I'm sure I'll find pizza somewhere.