I've always thought there was something special about Capitol. My girlfriends and I have been going there for almost 10 years and we will continue to do so for many years to come
True, it's not the busiest place on College and the ambiance is not as cozy or unique as, say Kalendar, but the food is delicious and the owners are some of the nicest people I've met. I always get the gnocchi con pesto and my girlfriend gets the pizza margherita. I would say the pastas outweigh the pizzas in terms of being excellent, but it all depends on how you like your Italian thin-crust pizzas! The salads are great and the wines are very reasonably-priced (ideal).
Capitol has reopened completely renovated after a fire a few months ago and it's lovely inside. The patio is very large and we often find ourselves there in the summer - easy to get a seat if one arrives early! In general the place doesn't get busy until later so it's a great option when you're hungry and want to eat right away.
4 stars from me!