I love old fashioned for their cheese curds and list of beers on tap. Those two things they do an amazing job at! And if I have guests in town I will take them here for those two things. But their food has always been a little mediocre in my opinion.
They do flights of their beer on tap which I enjoy to try new beers. They usually want you to pick a flight from the same line of taps. (Half of them are at one bar and the half at another) I believe they are color coded on the tap list.
I got their lake perch fish fry Wednesday special. The fish tasted fresh...I'm assuming it's not from lake monona. The fish came out a little cold. The French fries were good though. I've also gotten a brat there which again nothing amazing comes to mind about it.