Extremely overrated! I read all these reviews hoping to experience a slice of heaven and I can already tell you that Jimmy and Joe's, and Rays pizza is by far better.
The crust had no flavor and it was a little too thick for thin crust. The crust had too much yeast and you got full after too slices because of all the air in the crust thanks to the yeast overdose. The crust was also very dry and a bit hard. The toppings were good particularly the sausage.
The cheese gave it away as a phony. The way you distinguish between a real NY style pizza and a fake one (like this one) is through the cheese. Real places make their own mozzarella or acquire the real thing. Real mozzarrella should have an almost a rubbery consistency with a very salty aftertaste. If it tastes smooth and melts too evenly, it's not the real thing. I'm not saying it should clump but it should taste natural and this mozzarrela was not legit. In fact, it had no flavor The sauce lacked any zip to it. It was very plain and non acidic.
The bottomline is this place is hype. It has a great sounding name. The menu offers plenty of options to make this place sound good and it's pictures and website are nice but the pizza is average. I would not come back here