I've been here several times now and my conclusion is La Fontanella is very HIT and Miss.
In some ways La Fontanella is above average. They offer good service with crisp linens. The salads and the soups are usually good. The bread and seasoned oil is good. Some dinners like the Osso Bucos, the rabbit and usually the specials they do well. The house made gelato is also always good.
On the other hand not that Chicken Pollard isn't the greatest dish anywhere but that dish here is one I will never get again because it was just almost naked plain pounded dry chicken breast on a plate. After I had that dish I am afraid to order chicken again here. I have had the vegetable lasagna here before and it was good but the recent one I had was not the same. The sauce was very watery and oily and didn't taste right to me. I asked my husband to taste it and he said it didn't taste right to him either. Someone else at our table had the polenta bolognese lasagna and her's also didn't taste right. I think it just was a bad night for the sauce because both lasagnas had watery oily sauces that didn't taste good.
On the other hand the two people who had Pork Osso Buco and the Rabbit dish really enjoyed their meals.
Hit and Miss.