Overall: This place is average. The food was ok, the service was ok, the ambiance is ok.
Food: Decent Italian food. I had the lasagna, and it was fine. Nothing mindblowing, but certainly an acceptable lunch. Same for the soup.
Price: At $14-$20 for lunch, this is a typical decent-but-overpriced Old Montreal lunch place.
Conclusion: You can have a good lunch here. 3 stars because there's nothing outstanding or unique about it.